Комментарии Automated Trading Championship 2007

Hello Andreas

I would appreciate if you donate this money to the charity fund "Hope and beleive"  http://www.ucccf.com (site in Russian).

For wire transfers in EUR:

Beneficiary: BF "SPODIVAUS I VIRU" 
Account: 26007052702224 
Bank of beneficiary: 
PRIVATBANK 
DNEPROPETROVSK, UKRAINE 
SWIFT CODE: PBANUA2X 
Intermediary bank: 
DEUTSCHE BANK AG, 
Frankfurt am Main, Germany 
SWIFT CODE: DEUTDEFF 
Correspondent account: 94701211000 


For wire transfers in USD:

Beneficiary: BF "SPODIVAUS I VIRU" 
Account: 26005052701562 
Bank of beneficiary: 
PRIVATBANK 
DNEPROPETROVSK, UKRAINE 
SWIFT CODE: PBANUA2X 
Intermediary bank: 
JP MORGAN CHASE BANK 
CHASE METROTECH CENTER 
TH FLOOR BROOKLYN NY 11245 USA 
SWIFT CODE: CHASUS33 
Correspondent account: 011000080

Nashol odnu loghiceskuiu oshibku v funtiah MainShortOrder i MainLongOrder

int MainShortOrder () {
......
if(Y )
{
  result= OrderSend(Symbol(),OP_SELL,Lots,Bid,3,SL, sTP,"",mg,0,White); // step 1
 
   if (result==-1) // step 2
    {
      error=GetLastError();
      Print("error(",error,"): ",ErrorDescription(error));
       if(!IsTesting())
       {
          while(!( result>0 || TimeCurrent()-Begin>20)) // step 3
          {
            Sleep(1000);  
            RefreshRates();
            result= OrderSend(Symbol(),OP_SELL,Lots,Bid,3,SL,sTP,"",mg,0,White);
          }
        }
     }
           else  // step 4
           {
             total=OrdersTotal();
            ChangeLot();
            SelectData();
           }
   }
   return(result);
 }
}

Pri horish sticenii obstoiastelv snaciala budet step 1 (posilka odera) v step 2 provireatsa esli oder ushol normalino esli da to delaetsa step 4 i imeno:
             total=OrdersTotal();
            ChangeLot();
            SelectData();

No iesli order ne otoshleotsa normalino mi papadaem v step 2,3 , pitaemsea otoslati order poka eto u nas polucitsa, no posle etovo mi ne popadaem v step 4 i functie  ChangeLot(); ,  SelectData(); ne vizivaiutsa.

Tak shto esli na reale polucitsa requote, ili order ni otoshleotsa normalino to togda budet bu bu :)


Taje oshibka e v
-------------
int MainLongOrder() {
....
      res= OrderSend(Symbol(),OP_BUY,Lots,Ask,3,StL,
           bTkP,"",magic,0,Lime);

    if (res<0)
    {
      err=GetLastError();
      Print("error(",err,"): ",ErrorDescription(err));
    if(!IsTesting())
     {
      while(!( res>0 || TimeCurrent()-Begin>20))
      {
       Sleep(1000);   RefreshRates();
       res=OrderSend(Symbol(),OP_BUY,Lots,Ask,3,StL, bTkP,"",magic,0,Lime); // from here
      }
     }
   }
        else   { // we can't get here
       total=OrdersTotal();
       ChangeLot();
        SelectData(); }
}
    return(res);
}

-----------------------

Takje u menia iesti neskoliko voprosov k Mihailu

1. pervii eto functia TestInstall() , kak v vibiraete vremia i parametri dlia neio ?
naprimer:

if(TimeCurrent()<StrToTime("2007.06.2 00:00"))       // po kakomu printipu vi vibirate vremia
   {
     LocalTrend=Down;                                            // etot ?
    SetGlobVar("gLocalTrend"+Symbol(),LocalTrend);
     WaveNum=4;                                                  // i etot parametr ?
     SetGlobVar("gWaveNum"+Symbol(),WaveNum);}
      else
   if(TimeCurrent()<StrToTime("2007.07.17 00:00")) // same here
   {
     LocalTrend=Up;                                               // ?
     SetGlobVar("gLocalTrend"+Symbol(),LocalTrend);
    WaveNum=5;                                                  // ?
    SetGlobVar("gWaveNum"+Symbol(),WaveNum);
  }

2. Vtoroi vapros, budet li sovetnik rabotati v 2008 godu, ili parametri dlia stochastik/RSI/ADX/MA vibrani/optimizirovni toliko pod 2007 ?

3. ni hoteli bi v evo dalishe razvivati pri sovmestnom sotrudnicistve, na odnoi is forex comunity(forums) ?

Za ranee spasibo,
i udaci na realnih forex torgah.

may be manual....

I haven't found any deals closed the same bar as opened. The least hold time for an order was 18 minutes. Please show me the deal you're speaking about.

mas sugeng bagus banget ea-nya, ,mantep

Hi Better !

I'm sorry to say that your system dosen't cost one penny .

I studied all your trades . So far 380 trades , less than three months ,so I can say over 1000 lots in this modest account. If you want to use large money, in different markets, in different time frames ,then the money managers will lose their shorts .

How comes that your EA opens new position in a new bar and exits in the same bar. But this is not trading , this can be something else .

For sure , this Ea ,if will stay for a long time in trading at the end will lose all account . What I like to You that you are fighting with money management .

Belive me !- This is not trading . If the banks will use this system ,they will go bankrupt. Do you know what does it mean for a Bank Trader to put the initial stop 60-80 pips below the low of the signal bar. I saw over 200 real automated trading systems. But your system is not for trading ,sorry to say that . I never can use one system to enter and exit in the same bar. no ,no, no,,, ,,,, ,,,, not in trading my friend . the trading is not a joke , can give us a nice cutting hair .

the trading is not a joke again

Don't deceive yourself from the result . Be carefull

all the best

In english (with translator):

Tell, please, someone already bought this expert?
If yes, as all has passed, whether there are no reefs, whether the author gives source codes?
How the expert passes testing and whether works on real?
The price really small, I already asked the author.

Скажите, а кто-то уже покупал этого эксперта?
Если да, то как все прошло, нет ли подводных камней, предоставляет ли автор исходники?
Как эксперт проходит тестирование и работает ли на реале?
Цена действительно небольшая, я уже спрашивал у автора.

Hi brother !

I feel sorry for you. This is the second year for you , worse and worse. Be a good programmmer doesn't mean nothing that you are a good trader.

I know one trader from your country (Cairo).He doesn't know how to encode ,but when comes to the new ideas , this egyptian is a genius . He develops automated trading systems and and he is working in one idea that will bring the technical analysis into the highest level , ever exist before.

the name of this guy is Maged Lotfy . I will give you, without his permission ,his e-mail address.

absolute21@bellsouth.net

forget about crossover technique . I see here in three months over 300 -500 trades , I might say 2000 lots in only three months. This is not trading ,but might be something else. Even the champion's guy ,if he will stay for a long time in trading , he will lose the all account. He opens new position in a new bar and exits in tha same bar.This is not trading my friend .

all the best brother

Нашел ошибку в коде в функции StopSmallSellonDn(). Вот та часть кода

else
if(MainTrend==Down && LocalTrend==Down &&
CheckiMa(1440, 100, MODE_SMA, 1, 10)== Up &&

iStochastic(NULL,1440,8,3,3,MODE_SMA,0,MODE_MAIN,0)<25) // !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

{WaitSmallDn=NoSignal;
SetGlobVar("gWaitSmallDn"+Symbol(),NoSignal);
}

По-идее должно быть так

...

iStochastic(NULL,1440,8,3,3,MODE_SMA,0,MODE_MAIN,0)<10

...